Court of Appeals of Texas August 13, 1997, No. 06-96-00092-CV (Newsom v. Whittington)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-08-1997

OPINION

ROSS, Justice.

Jimmie Newsom brought this cause of action, claiming damages from a fire originat*412ing on O.P. Whittington’s property. New-som appeals from a judgment finding that Whittington did not negligently permit the accumulation of debris on land that he possessed. In his points of error, Newsom claims Whittington was negligent as a matter of law and that the jury verdict was not supported by the evidence or was against the great weight and preponderance of the evidence. He also claims that Whittington was negligent per se because he violated the Houston fire code, that the evidence was factually insufficient to support the jury’s damages finding, and that the judgment was erroneous because it was based on irreconcilable jury answers. The judgment is affirmed.

I.

Facts

This case' concerns a fire that started in some mattress debris behind a business called Slumberland on Old Spanish Trail in Houston.

A. Whittington’s Property

In November 1989, Whittington purchased a piece of property fronting Old Spanish Trail on the south and Griggs Road on the north. The portion fronting Old Spanish Trail was already occupied by a used mattress company called Slumberland, owned by Samuel 0. Pitts. When he purchased the property, Whittington got a price reduction in order to pay for a massive cleanup of the area occupied by Slumberland. In the months after he purchased the property, Whittington arranged for repairs to the building occupied by Slumberland and arranged for the cleanup of the portion of the open yard used by Slumberland. Whitting-ton used the property not occupied by Pitts to operate General Supply & Equipment (Gensco), which collected and sold used aircraft tires.

Whittington’s property had three buildings on it: a masonry building, a metal warehouse, and a metal shed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.