Court of Appeals of Georgia January 13, 1997, A96A1643 (Department of Transportation v. Scott)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-01-1997

Pope, Presiding Judge.

The Department of Transportation (“DOT”) appeals the jury’s condemnation award for a strip of land consisting of 1.692 acres lying south of Georgia Highway 16 in Spalding County. The land taken was part of a 96-acre tract owned by condemnee, C. Marion Scott, lying north and south of the highway. Condemnee Ison Nursery & Vineyards, Inc. is the lessee of the 60 acres lying south of the highway from which the strip was taken.

*232At the time of condemnation, Ison had growing on the strip of condemned property approximately 950 muscadine grape plants, referred to as “mother plants,” which were taken and destroyed in the condemnation. These “mother plants” were not grown to bear fruit or be sold, rather they were used to produce the plants, or cuttings, which were sold by the nursery. Ison grows many different varieties of muscadines some of which have been patented in its name. The “mother plants” for two of the patented varieties, as well as other non-patented varieties, were located on the condemned property. Moving or transplanting the “mother plants” was not possible because of their age and maturity and their extensive root system development. Although the replacement cost of the patented “mother plants” was only $14,623, evidence at trial showed that the destruction of the plants taken would result in loss of sales of approximately 60,000-65,000 plants per year with a resulting business loss of $214,000 over the three-year period of time required to replace the taken “mother plants” with new ones.

DOT contended $4,738 was just and adequate compensation for the value of land, and $6,083 was just and adequate consideration for the muscadine plants. However, the jury awarded Scott $12,000 as just and adequate compensation for his property, and awarded Ison $100,000. DOT appeals, raising ten enumerations of error.

1.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.