Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York April 17, 1997 (Urbach v. Farrell)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-04-1997

OPINION OF THE COURT

Cardona, P. J.

Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Hughes, J.), entered July 26,1996 in Albany County, which partially denied petitioner’s motion pursuant to CPLR 2304 to, inter alia, quash a subpoena duces tecum.

In 1995, the Legislature approved a proposal permitting petitioner, the Commissioner of Taxation and Finance, to enter into a contract with respondent Fleet Bank known as PIT 2000, for the purpose of privatizing the processing of the State’s personal income tax returns. Initially, Fleet leased office space for this purpose in the Albany area. In September 1995, the Governor reached an agreement with Fleet to expand PIT 2000 and relocate its operations to vacant IBM buildings near the City of Kingston, Ulster County. The proposal was approved by the Attorney-General but objections by the Comptroller prompted a revision of the plan from a lease-purchase of the IBM buildings by the State for Fleet to a direct lease between IBM and Fleet. This proposal was approved by the Comptroller on April 15, 1996.

On or about April 22, 1996, the State Assembly’s Ways and Means Committee (hereinafter Committee) issued a legislative subpoena to petitioner directing his appearance at a hearing and seeking, inter alia, production of a complete copy of PIT 2000. Prior to issuing the subpoena, respondent Herman D. *277Farrell, Jr., the Committee’s Chair, informally requested a complete signed copy of PIT 2000. Citing the need to protect Fleet’s trade secret status for portions of PIT 2000, which petitioner had granted under the State’s Freedom of Information Law (hereinafter FOIL),1 petitioner supplied only redacted versions of the contract to the Committee. After Farrell refused petitioner’s request to withdraw the subpoena, petitioner commenced this special proceeding to quash or modify the subpoena.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.