Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York April 15, 1997 (People v. Cuiman)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-04-1997

OPINION OF THE COURT

Murphy, P. J.

On January 4, 1993, five persons were robbed at knifepoint in an apartment elevator in Manhattan’s Rangle Projects. The single victim able to describe the assailant’s face to police portrayed him as a light-skinned black man, about 5 feet, 6 inches tall, with light facial hair but no beard, and without glasses. Later that day, viewing a book of mug shots provided to her by Detective Carlos Diaz, the complainant identified defendant Robert Cuiman as her attacker; she also identified defendant in a police lineup one day later. At the time of his arrest, defendant was 5 feet, 8 inches tall, wore eyeglasses, and bore a light mustache and beard.

Because defendant’s appearance at the time of the lineup differed in several respects from the initial description of the assailant that the complainant gave to police, and as no other convincing physical evidence was discovered to connect defendant with the crime, the central issue at trial was the accuracy of the complainant’s eyewitness testimony. Especially in its cross-examination of the complainant, the defense sought to highlight incongruities between her initial description and her lineup identification. The People made no effort to rebut this cross-examination, and no mention was made of the photo identification in the course of the complainant’s testimony. Later, while cross-examining Detective Diaz, the defense inquired into the physical evidence linking defendant with the crime, the differences between the physical description provided by the witness and the appearance presented by defendant at the lineup, and the failure of the police to secure a warrant or conduct a search upon the defendant’s arrest. Once *282again, no mention of the photo identification was made in the direct or cross-examination of Detective Diaz.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.