Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York May 8, 1997 (In re Shawn BB.)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-05-1997
Casey, J.
As a result of findings of neglect and/or abuse by their biological parents, Shawn (born in 1989), Ashleigh (born in 1990) and Samuel (born in 1992), the three children who are the subject of these proceedings, were placed with the Johnston County Department of Social Services (hereinafter JCDSS) in North Carolina. Pending approval of custody and permanent placement pursuant to the Interstate Compact on the Placement of Children (see, Social Services Law § 374-a), JCDSS permitted respondents, the children’s maternal aunt and uncle, to take the children to Cortland County on an "extended visit”.
*679The present abuse/neglect petitions stem from a hotline report dated February 23, 1996 which alleged that Ashleigh had bruising on her neck and shoulder as a result of excessive corporal punishment inflicted by respondents the previous day. Upon being informed of these allegations by petitioner, JCDSS sent a caseworker to take the children back to North Carolina on February 26, 1996. Respondents failed, however, to deliver the children to the airport at the scheduled time and stopped sending them to school. As a result, petitioner sought and received permission from Family Court to temporarily remove the children from respondents’ home. A fact-finding hearing was ultimately held after which Family Court dismissed the abuse/neglect petitions against respondents. Petitioner now appeals.
Initially, we note that although Family Court found that the proof showed improper physical disciplining of Ashleigh, it dismissed the petitions based on its belief that "this one act” was offset by the fact that the children "have been in the only decent environment that they have ever enjoyed”. In essence, therefore, the court inappropriately engaged in a best interest analysis at the fact-finding stage of the proceeding instead of making a determination based on the preponderance of the evidence as required (see, Family Ct Act § 1046 [b] [i]; Matter of Nicole V.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit