Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York July 3, 1997, Appeal No. 2 (In re Daniel R.)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-07-1997

Order unanimously reversed on the law and facts without costs, petition granted and matter remitted to Niagara County Family Court for further proceedings in accordance with the following Memorandum: Following a fact-finding hearing, Family Court dismissed the petition alleging that respondent had abused and/or neglected his three-year-old son. The court found that the testimony of the various wit*957nesses presented by petitioner was credible and that the child sustained the injuries alleged in the petition, but further found that respondent offered an explanation of the injuries that was equally credible. The court found that petitioner failed to meet its burden of proving by a preponderance of the credible evidence that the injuries were caused by respondent. Upon our review of the record, we find that, although the evidence does not support a finding of abuse, it does support a finding that the child was neglected within the meaning of the Family Court Act.

Petitioner’s proof that the child sustained injuries that would not ordinarily occur absent an act or omission of respondent constitutes a prima facie case of neglect (see, Family Ct Act § 1046 [a] [ii]; Matter of Philip M., 82 NY2d 238, 243-244; Matter of Briana R., 236 AD2d 830). Contrary to the court’s finding, however, we conclude that respondent failed to rebut that prima facie case with credible evidence demonstrating that the injuries to the child could reasonably have occurred accidentally without respondent’s acts or omissions (see, Matter of Philip M., supra, at 244; Matter of Briana R., supra). Although respondent offered proof that the child was “clumsy” and fell down quite a bit, that proof would not explain the adult bite marks on the child’s leg nor the large X-shaped scratches on the child’s back. Respondent’s proof also fails to explain the child’s failure to thrive while in respondent’s care and custody.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.