New York Family Court July 1, 1997 (In re an Application for News Media Coverage)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-07-1997

OPINION OF THE COURT

Howard Spitz, J.

A human tragedy of great personal and societal proportions occurred on June 1, 1997, when Dr. B. S., an esteemed public figure and spokesperson for human rights, sustained third degree burns to more than 80%- of her body in a fire at her home. Her 12-year-old grandson is accused of setting the fire and is the respondent in this juvenile delinquency proceeding before the court. Dr. S. died on June 23, 1997.

Both the particular circumstances of the case and the general climate in which it occurs have made these proceedings the focus of intense public interest. Not only was Dr. S. a remarkable woman in her own right, she was the widow of civil rights leader M., and the respondent is their grandson. The alleged crime has occurred at a time when there is heightened concern about increased juvenile and domestic violence and a perception that Family Court proceedings are veiled in secrecy. The concern and interest in this case has resulted in phone calls, letters and faxes to the court and in requests by representatives of the print and broadcast media to cover the proceedings.

At the first hearing in this matter on June 2, 1997, a pool of four reporters was admitted into the courtroom, and no objection was raised by the parties. On the following day, June 3, 1997, four reporters and a sketch artist were admitted. Counsel for the respondent orally objected to the presence of the press based on a general statement of potential harm to the respondent. The County Attorney took no position at that time. The *658court denied respondent’s application to exclude the press, recognizing the presumption of openness of court proceedings, but with the qualification of possible future closure. At the third session on June 6, 1997, with four reporters and a sketch artist present in the courtroom, both parties to the proceeding sought closure to the press.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.