New York Supreme Court September 3, 1997 (In re Anonymous)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-09-1997

*334OPINION OF THE COURT

Abraham G. Gerges, J.

Is an insanity acquittee entitled to have the court record sealed (CPL 160.50)? Is such an acquittee entitled to have potential employers disregard the arrest for employment purposes (see, CPL 160.60; Executive Law § 296 [16])? Is an insanity acquittee entitled to the return of the entire bail posted without reduction of the 2% charge (General Municipal Law § 99-m [1])? Can such an acquittee require the return of the vehicle used in the course of the crime (Vehicle and Traffic Law § 511-c [5] [a] [i])? The applicability of these and other statutes is determined by the issue of whether an insanity acquittee’s not guilty verdict is a termination in favor of defendant.

Movant/petitioner requests "unsealing” or, more precisely, a declaration that the records of indictment No. 538/78 were improperly sealed.

In February 1978, acquittee killed his wife and three children, one of whom was blind and "multiply handicapped”.* The incident received widespread publicity. As a result of a nonjury trial, acquittee was found "not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect” (see, CPL 300.10 [former (3) (d)]). The Clerk of this court then stamped all records sealed pursuant to CPL 160.50.

It is noted that acquittee was disbarred as a result of this incident and his recent attempts at reinstatement have been rejected. Acquittee has made a new life for himself and for his new family.

In 1997 movant /petitioner was retained by Random House to author a book regarding members of the Industrial Home for the Blind in the 1970’s. At that time, movant/petitioner was a "reporter and critic” for the Wall Street Journal and was aware of some of the underlying facts regarding the instant indictment and acquittee’s involvement with the Industrial Home for the Blind. In an effort to cull more "accurate” information about the occurrence, movant /petitioner went to the Clerk’s office attempting to examine the court file.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.