Civil Court of the City of New York December 4, 1997 (Alawlaqi v. Kelly)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-12-1997

OPINION OF THE COURT

Carl O. Callender, J.

In the instant proceeding one of the issues presented is may a private landlord in a section 8 subsidized program (see, 42 USC § 1437f) or with a section 8 tenant serve the New York City Housing Authority (NYCHA) in any manner it chooses when it is evident that the NYCHA has no objection to a holdover eviction proceeding against the tenant. The key point of reference is the case of Williams v New York City Hous. *571Axah. (US Dist Ct, SD NY 1995, Ward, J., 81 Civ 1801). In that case a consent decree was issued by the Honorable Robert J. Ward. It required that in a good cause eviction proceeding, such as the instant personal family use case, the NYCHA must be served the petition and notice of petition as the State law requires, or by overnight mail. The order makes no other method of delivery available to the private landlord. The NYCHA is normally available and open to receive service of papers from 9:00 a.m. through 5:00 p.m. during weekdays. For reasons that are unclear to the court, the process server only mailed the papers to the NYCHA.

The attorney for the petitioner argues that regular mail delivery of the papers to NYCHA is reasonable and proper since the NYCHA had already indicated that it had no objection to the bringing of a holdover eviction proceeding against the respondent. The attorney for the respondent contends that the only legally appropriate methods of service or delivery are those contained within the confines of the Williams decree. A careful reading of the decree makes it clear that unless the method of service or delivery is permitted by the decree, it constitutes a basis for dismissal of the eviction proceeding. The Williams consent judgment itself states that “its provisions govern the New York City Housing Authority’s role in eviction proceedings brought by private landlords in the Section 8 program administered by the Authority against Section 8 tenants.” (See, Williams decree ¶ 1.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.