Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Westmoreland County July 2, 1997, no. 3253 of 1996 (Smalich v. PennDOT)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-07-1997

LOUGHRAN, J.,

— The instant case arises from a one-vehicle accident that occurred on Pennsylvania State Route 981 on February 10, 1996 in Mount Pleasant Township, Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania. The plaintiff’s decedent, Mary K. Smalich, allegedly lost control of her vehicle on an ice patch, resulting in an accident in which she died. PennDOT, as well as the adjoining property owner, have been sued allegedly due to a drainage problem which created the ice patch, which in turn caused the accident. Plaintiff has also alleged in the second amended complaint that PennDOT was negligent in failing to construct and maintain guiderail on S.R. 981 thereby creating a dangerous condition.

PennDOT has filed preliminary objections as to the guiderail negligence paragraphs and as to certain items of damages. Specifically, in addition to a claim filed by the administrator of the estate, a separate and distinct claim in the caption of the amended complaint has been filed by Jessica Suhan, a minor, by Jeremy Suhan, her father and natural guardian. These claims are set forth with more particularity in paragraphs 22 through 26 of the plaintiffs’ amended complaint.

In the plaintiffs’ amended complaint, it is asserted that it is proper to have claims by two plaintiffs, since PennDOT can be sued in both a wrongful death and survival cause of action. It is PennDOT’s position that while both a survival and wrongful death cause of action may be asserted, these claims must be asserted by one plaintiff and that the proper plaintiff would be the administrator of the estate.

The plaintiffs have filed preliminary objections to PennDOT’s preliminary objections pertaining to the guiderails. The plaintiffs contend that PennDOT should have raised the guiderail matter raising sovereign im*66munity by new matter in accordance with Rule 1030 of the Rules of Civil Procedure.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.