Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court July 21, 1997 (Kolodziej v. Smith)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-07-1997

O’Connor, J.

This case is before us for the second time. The plaintiff brought an action against the defendants, Electro-Term, Inc., and its president, Warren Smith, after she was punished for *519refusing to attend a company-mandated seminar. The defendants were granted directed verdicts and Kolodziej appealed. This court affirmed the judgment for the defendants, Kolodziej v. Smith, 412 Mass. 215 (1992) (Kolodziej I), but, in light of a then recent decision by the United States Supreme Court, Yellow Freight Sys., Inc. v. Donnelly, 494 U.S. 820, 825 (1990), holding that State courts may adjudicate claims brought under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended, 42 U.S.C. §§ 2000e et seq. (1988) (Title VII), we remanded the case to give Kolodziej an opportunity to amend her complaint to include that Federal claim. Kolodziej I, supra at 222-223.

Kolodziej’s amended complaint, which was based on the same underlying facts as her initial complaint, alleged religious discrimination in violation of Title VII. The case was tried to a jury in the Superior Court. Ten written questions, agreed on by the parties, were submitted to the jury. The first four questions and the jury’s answers were as follows:

“1. Did the Defendants require Plaintiff to attend a ‘devotional service’? A. Yes X No_.

“2. Did the attendance at the seminar conflict with the Plaintiff’s bona fide personal religious beliefs? A. Yes_ NoX.

“If the answers to both question no. 1 and question no. 2 are ‘NO’, please date and sign the form. If the answer to either question no. 1 or question no. 2 is ‘YES’, please continue.

“3. Did the Plaintiff give notice to the Defendants that attendance at the seminar conflicted with her bona fide personal religious beliefs?

“If the answer is ‘NO’, please date and sign this form. If the answer is ‘YES’, please continue. A. Yes X No_.

“4.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.