Court of Appeals of Arkansas December 10, 1997, CA 97-425 (Phillips v. Mission Fellowship Bible Church)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-12-1997

Andree Layton Roaf, Judge.

Washington County Assessor Sue Phillips (assessor) appeals a circuit court finding upholding a tax exemption for the appellee Mission Fellowship Bible Church (church) for a building and the 1.05-acre tract of land that it sits on. On appeal, the assessor argues that the circuit court erred in finding that the property was not the property of the church’s pastor, Rev. Jay D. Cole, and his wife, Thelma G. Cole, or in the alternative, that the church was not entitled to a tax exemption for the entire 1.05 acres. We affirm.

The church has existed as a domestic nonprofit corporation since 1991. Under I.R.S. guidelines, it qualifies as a church for federal tax-exempt status. The church is governed by a three-member board, elected by the congregation upon the recommendation of Rev. Cole. At the time this matter was litigated, Rev. Cole was a board member. Rev. Cole is an ordained Baptist minister, and the church’s congregation has some seventy “attendees.” Sunday worship service attendance varies between twenty-ñve and thirty-eight. All services are advertised and open to the public.

The property in question is a 1.05-acre tract upon which is situated the church building, a 6,800 square-foot structure that contains a sanctuary, chapel, Sunday School classrooms, a religious lending library, fellowship areas, administrative offices, and guest quarters for visiting pastors and missionaries. The balance of the property consists of landscaped grounds, approach roads, and a parking area. The 1.05-acre tract was part of a fifty-five-acre tract that was subject to a number of transactions between 1975 and 1992 involving the Coles as individual owners and Rev. Cole as an officer of a succession of nonprofit corporations engaged in religious activities.

Originally, the fifty-five-acre tract was acquired by Rev. and Mrs. Cole in November 1975, but was conveyed a month later by correction deed to United Missionary Aviation, Inc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.