Court of Appeals of Washington September 22, 1997, No. 37844-9-I (Bishop v. Miche)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-09-1997

Grosse, J.

— Actions or inactions relating to a probation officer’s awareness of an error in sentencing are protected by quasi-judicial immunity and shield the officer’s employer from liability as well as the officer. However, a county may be held liable if a probation officer has failed in his or her duty to enforce a convicted criminal’s sentencing conditions by reporting probation violations. Because material issues of fact remain as to whether the probation officer acted negligently in carrying out her duties, the trial court erred in dismissing the negligent supervision claim at issue here.

FACTS

When driving while intoxicated, Steven Miche was involved in an accident which killed five-year-old Alexander Bishop. This fatality was the culmination of Miche’s long history of driving while intoxicated. At the time he killed Alexander Bishop, he was on probation for a suspended sentence for driving a vehicle while under the influence of intoxicating liquor (DUI). He received a one-year suspended sentence because the trial court failed to realize that Miche was using an alias under which no previous convictions were recorded. His real driving record revealed three DUI convictions in the previous four years, driving with a suspended license, a revocation of his driver’s license, and outstanding warrants from municipal court.

Instead of ordering jail time, the trial court placed Miche under the supervision of a probation officer. Because the driving record under his alias noted that his driver’s license had been canceled due to a "fraudulent application,” Miche’s probation officer quickly realized that Miche’s full record had not been before the court. The next day, the officer sent an advisory report to the district court advising it that "Steven W. Williams also appears to use an AKA of Steven W. Miche. DOL records are maintained under MICHE, STEVEN WALTER . . . and driving privileges are revoked.” No action resulted from this notification.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.