Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit October 22, 1997, No. 96-35766 (Montana v. Gilham)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-10-1997

THOMAS, Circuit Judge:

This appeal raises the question of whether the State of Montana may be subject to an unconsented tort action filed by an individual plaintiff in Blackfeet Tribal Court. We hold that Montana’s sovereign immunity bars such' an action.

I

Our consideration of these questions of dominion and authority has its genesis in a personal tragedy. On January 14, 1986, Christine Gilham was fatally injured when the car in which she was a passenger struck a permanently anchored highway sign at the intersection of U.S. Highways 2 and 89 within the external boundaries of the Blackfeet Indian Reservation, located in the State of Montana. Toni Gilham (“Gilham”), Christine’s mother, brought an action against the driver of the car, who was intoxicated at the time of the accident, and the State of Montana (“Montana”) in the Blackfeet Tribal Court. She alleged that Montana was negligent in its design, construction, and maintenance of the intersection.

*899Montana filed a motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction, arguing that as a sovereign it is immune from suit in the Blackfeet Tribal Court absent a waiver of its sovereign immunity. The tribal court denied the motion, and the case proceeded to trial. The jury returned a verdict against the driver and Montana for $280,000. After application of comparative negligence and distribution of the proceeds of the driver’s insurance policy, judgment was entered against the defendants rendering them jointly and severally liable for $159,664.92. Montana unsuccessfully appealed the immunity issue to the Blackfeet Court of Appeals and the Blackfeet Supreme Court, both courts affirming the trial court’s ruling. The courts found that Article II, § 18 of the Constitution of Montana waived Montana’s immunity from suit in the tribal courts. The Blackfeet Supreme Court remanded the case to the tribal court for further proceedings on issues unrelated to the sovereign immunity question.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.