New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division November 17, 1997 (Gaglioti Contracting, Inc. v. City of Hoboken)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-11-1997
The opinion of the court was delivered by
NEWMAN, J.A.D.
This action arises out of the award of a public contract by defendant City of Hoboken (Hoboken) to defendant La Rocca, Inc. *424(LaRocca), the second lowest bidder, instead of to plaintiff Gaglioti Contracting, Inc. (Gaglioti), the lowest bidder. Hoboken bypassed Gaglioti because of Gaglioti’s failure to submit the names of its subcontractors to be used on the job with its bid documents. Gaglioti appeals. We affirm.
The relevant facts are not in dispute. On August 15, 1996, Hoboken posted a Notice to Bidders soliciting bids for construction of the North Park project in Hoboken. The notice called for the submission of bids no later than October 24,1996.
The project entailed (1) seawall repair, pier removal and replacement, (2) the creation of a public park, complete with a new soccer field and a waterfront pavilion, and (3) a new building. Originally, Hoboken divided the project into the above three components, allowing contractors to bid on one, two or all three segments at their option. Although the project was divided into three sections, the plans and specifications accompanying the notice to bidders were not. One set of plans and specifications existed for all three components of the project.
After Hoboken opened the bids, it at once recognized that its three-component method was too confusing, as each portion of each contractor’s bid varied widely from one contractor to the next. Consequently, Hoboken determined to rebid the project without dividing the tasks. Hoboken’s rebid package, including the plans and specifications, was the same as that for the original bid, except that it called for a “lump sum” bid, and it reduced the cash allowance for unforeseen additional work from $50,000 to $10,000. Rebids were due by December 2,1996.
Hoboken opened the bids at 2:00 p.m. on December 2, 1996. The lowest bidder was Gaglioti, who submitted a bid in the amount of $2,364,800.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit