Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit November 21, 1997, 96-1214, 96-1237 (Richardson-Vicks Inc. v. The Upjohn Company, Defendant/cross-Appellant, and McNeil Inc. And Johnson & Johnson)

PLAGE R, Circuit Judge.

In this case, a jury found the patent on a popular cough and cold formula not invalid for obviousness and not unenforceable. Subsequently, the trial judge overturned the jury verdict. Plaintiff appeals the trial judge’s action.