Louisiana Court of Appeal April 29, 1997, No. 96-CA-1079 (Desoto v. Desoto)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-04-1997

JiWTCKER, Judge.

Lydia Sehexnayder DeSoto appeals a judgment adopting a proposed consent judgment appellant had refused to sign. We reverse and remand.

Lydia DeSoto and Errol DeSoto were divorced in 1978 and the community property was partitioned in a written consent agreement. The partition agreement made no mention of Errol’s pension and retirement benefits. At the time he had not yet retired.

In 1990, after Errol DeSoto had retired, Lydia DeSoto filed a supplemental petition for partition of the community, asserting she was entitled to a share in Errol’s retirement benefits. Errol filed an answer and recon-ventional demand, seeking to have the original community property partition annulled.

Thereafter counsel for the parties began negotiating a compromise. On October 18, 1995 Errol’s attorney sent a letter to Lydia’s attorney, which included calculations showing Lydia’s share of Errol’s monthly benefit as $133.23. The letter made the following proposal:

In order to put this matter to rest my client is willing to settle as follows:

1. Pay unto your client the sum of $5,000.00.

2. Arrange that she receive $133.23 per month beginning November 1,1995.

3. Dismiss any claims he has against the community estate and your client.

Lin consideration of this your client would be willing to:

1. Dismiss any claims she has against the community estate and my client.

2. Sign a judgment terminating the $100.00 per month alimony which Mr. DeSoto now pays to her.

On February 1, 1996 Lydia’s counsel sent Errol’s attorney a letter that stated:

[Lydia] has agreed to accept the percentile computations which you had forwarded in your first letter.

As I understand it, we are, therefore, agreed as follows:

a. Lydia is to receive the monthly income detailed in your letter;

b. All back payments computed on the same percentile are to be paid forthwith;

c. These actions are taken without regard to the current status of the alimony claim.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.