Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama October 10, 1997, 2960766 (Birmingham Lumber & Building Materials, Inc. v. Lovejoy)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-10-1997

L. CHARLES WRIGHT, Retired Appellate Judge.

Lyman A. Lovejoy filed a declaratory judgment action against Birmingham Lumber and Building Materials, Inc. Lovejoy was seeking to determine the legal consequence of a judgment which purported to confirm and perfect a lien on real property that he had acquired after the lien was filed, but before it was perfected. Lovejoy was not a party to the lawsuit that was filed to perfect the lien. In the instant suit, the trial court entered a summary judgment in favor of Lovejoy; Birmingham Lumber appealed. This case has been transferred to this court by our supreme court, pursuant to Ala.Code 1975, § 12-2-7(6).

In December 1994 Birmingham Lumber filed a materialman’s lien against Lot 30, Hickory Lane Estates, in St. Clair County. At that time, title to that lot was vested in James Dean Isdell. In January 1995 Isdell transferred title to that lot to Lyman Love-joy. In February 1995 Birmingham Lumber filed an action against Isdell on an open account to perfect the materialman’s lien on Lot 30, Hickory Lane Estates. In May 1995 a judgment was entered against Isdell, awarding Birmingham Lumber $67,045.71, a portion of which ($14,808.24) was awarded in connection with the materialman’s hen. A certificate of judgment was recorded in the Probate Court of St. Clair County, which purported to confirm and perfect the hen for $14,808.24 against Lot 30, Hickory Lane Estates. Subsequently, Lovejoy discovered the cloud on the title to that lot and filed a declaratory action, challenging the validity of the judgment perfecting the hen against Lot 30, Hickory Lane Estates. Birmingham Lumber contended that the hen was vahd against Lovejoy and that it was not necessary to join Lovejoy as a party to the suit perfecting the hen because it had no notice of his interest in the property. The trial court held that by virtue of Ala.Code 1975, § 35-11-223, Lovejoy was a necessary and proper party to the action to perfect and enforce the hen.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.