High Court of American Samoa March 4, 1997, CA No. 121-95 (Masaniai v. Tedrick)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-03-1997
Order on Motion to Dismiss:
Defendants Apoua and Bill Tedrick, d.b.a. The Country Club, ("defendants") move to dismiss plaintiffs second cause of action entitled in his complaint as "Serving Alcoholic Beverages to an Intoxicated Individual." Plaintiff seeks to impose tort liability on the defendants based on the factual assertions that the plaintiff sustained injuries as a result of the defendants' serving him alcohol after he was intoxicated, in violation of A.S.C.A. §27.0531 (a)(2). Plaintiff alleges that on the evening/early morning of February 25-26, 1995, he was drinking intoxicating liquor at the Country Club, and that the Country Club's employees allowed him to enter and then served him alcohol while he was intoxicated. He further asserts that in the course of the evening, he was involved in an altercation inside the Country Club and was ejected from the premises by an employee of defendants, and that the altercation continued outside of the Country Club in the parking lot where plaintiff was injured. He now claims that his intoxication contributed to the cause of his injuries. Although plaintiff has asserted four separate causes of action, defendants are only moving to dismiss the second.1
DISCUSSION
In reviewing a motion to dismiss brought pursuant to T.C.R.C.P. 12(b)(6), the complaint must be liberally construed in the light most *188favorable to the plaintiff. Beaver v. Cravens, 17 A.S.R.2d 6, 8 (Trial Div. 1990).
Under common law, a seller of alcohol does not owe any duty based solely on the serving of alcoholic beverages to an obviously intoxicated consumer. Absent statute, no cause of action may lay against the seller of alcohol in favor of those injured by the intoxicated consumer. 45 Am. JUR. 2d Intoxicating Liquors, § 553 (1969 & supp. 1993). The reason often given for the rule is that it is the drinking of the alcohol, and not the furnishing of it, that is the proximate cause of the injury. Id.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit