Spotsylvania County Circuit Court March 17, 1997, Case No. CL95-494 (Hall v. Akers)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-03-1997

By Judge William H. Ledbetter, Jr.

In a post-verdict motion, the plaintiff asks the court to set aside the jury verdict, or to require additur, on the ground that the award reflects only the plaintiffs proven “specials” and ignores other elements of damages established by the evidence.

Facts

This personal injury case arises out of an automobile accident on Route 3 in Spotsylvania County on October 17,1994. The defendant struck the rear of the plaintiíf s vehicle causing relatively minor property damage. The plaintiff was not transported to a hospital from the scene. However, when she began to experience pain and discomfort later that evening, she went to the emergency room where she was x-rayed and treated for a cervical sprain. Three days later, she visited Dr. Kurt Larson, an orthopedic surgeon, who confirmed the ER diagnosis and treated her on three occasions. He recommended rest and physical therapy. The plaintiff missed 13 days’ work and attended six physical therapy sessions.

The case was tried with a jury on February 7,1997. The defendant admitted liability. Thus, the only issue for the jury to determine was the amount of damages to which the plaintiff was entitled.

*502According to Dr. Larson’s testimony, the plaintiffs cervical sprain was caused by the accident, and the medical expenses she incurred were reasonable and necessaiy. The plaintiff offered as evidence, without objection, medical bills totalling $1,316.65. The parties stipulated that the 13 missed work days would constitute lost wages of $1,493.44. Thus, the plaintiffs “specials” totaled $2,810.09.

In addition, Dr. Larson and the plaintiff testified about the effect and duration of the pain and discomfort associated with the injury, and the plaintiff testified about die difficulties, including the inconvenience, caused by the need for six physical therapy sessions.

The court instructed the jury, inter alia, that it could consider five elements in determining damages.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.