Spotsylvania County Circuit Court March 28, 1997, Case No. CL96-352 (Press v. Purks)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-03-1997

By Judge William H. Ledbetter, Jr.

This detinue action presents questions about the manner by which a secured creditor repossessed collateral and allegedly thwarted the debtor’s rights to redeem it.

Facts

In December of 1992, the plaintiff (Press) purchased a registered quarter horse from the defendant (Purks) for $5,500.00. The parties signed a contract dated December 27,1992, in which Purks retained a security interest in the horse to secure the unpaid portion of the purchase price.

After making payments for a considerable time, Press defaulted. Purks obtained a judgment against Press for the outstanding balance ($1,306.19) on May 15, 1996, in general district court.

On May 31,1996, Purks repossessed the horse.

When Press learned that Purks had taken the horse from the farm where he boarded it, he telephoned Purks. Press says that he called Purks the next day, June 1, 1996, and told her that he would pay all amounts owed on the judgment. He requested that she return the horse to the boarding farm upon such payment. He further contends that Purks said she would not return the horse until Press paid the judgment for the purchase price balance and the *540amount of an April 17, 1995, judgment she had obtained against him for training and hauling the horse. (After she had sold the horse to Press, Purks served as a trainer and accompanied his daughter to horse shows, under a separate agreement.)

Purks denies that she had any conversation with Press on June 1,1996. She says that Press did not contact her until the end of June 1996, at which time he demanded that she return the horse and that he would “have a check waiting” for the amount of the judgment. In a later conversation, she says, she told Press that she had incurred other expenses related to the repossession that must be paid before she would return the horse.

Press initiated this litigation by filing a warrant in detinue in general district court on July 3, 1996.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.