Fairfax County Circuit Court May 21, 1997, Case No. (Law) 156546 (Adkins v. Fairfax County School Board)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-05-1997

By Judge Stanley P. Klein

This matter is before the Court on Defendant Dr. Teressa Caldwell’s Demurrer and Plea of Sovereign Immunity to Count in of the First Amended Motion for Judgment.1 The Court has considered the arguments, both oral and written, made by counsel as well as the authorities relied on by each. Based on the allegations of negligence set forth in the First Amended Motion for Judgment, Caldwell’s Demurrer is sustained as to Count HI, and Count HI is accordingly dismissed.

I. Background

This case stems from an incident which allegedly occurred between Plaintiff, Dora Adkins, a teacher at McLean High School, and the principal of that school, Defendant Caldwell. Adkins alleged that Caldwell defamed her in front of her students when she accused Adkins of lying about a donated computer she was supposed to deliver to the school. Adkins brought suit against Caldwell and the Fairfax County School Board. Based on the Court’s May 9th rulings, Fairfax County School Board is no longer in this lawsuit, as all claims against it were dismissed with prejudice.

*306II. Caldwell’s Demurrer to Count III

Count El of the First Amended Motion for Judgment is titled “Negligence.” Incorporating all of the previous allegations, Plaintiff states “[i]n doing the things herein alleged, Defendants, and each of them, acted negligently.” First Amended Motion for Judgment, ¶ 26. Due to this negligence, “Plaintiff suffered the damages described in Paragraph 11.” Id. at ¶ 27. In paragraph 11, Plaintiff alleged that she “suffered embarrassment, humiliation, mental anguish, inconvenience, loss of enjoyment of life as well as emotional stress.”

Caldwell demurred based on the ground that she was not adequately put on notice of what the claim is. This was the reason the Court sustained her demurrer to Count IE of the original Motion for Judgment. No substantive changes were made to Count IE in the First Amended Motion for Judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.