Rockingham County Circuit Court July 2, 1997 (In re Phillips)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-07-1997

By Judge John J. McGrath, Jr.

The Petitioner, the father of the three minors listed above, seeks appointment as Guardian of his children under §§ 31-4 to 31-6 of the Code of Virginia for the sole purpose of disclaiming any interest his children may have in an inter vivos trust created by their maternal grandfather. These disclaimers would be part of a family scheme for the decedent’s widow, his children, and his grandchildren to disclaim certain deferred payments which would go to the inter vivos trust subject to estate tax and instead for the payments to go by intestacy to the widow and thus be sheltered from taxation by the marital deduction.

The immediate effect of such disclaimer is to increase the net amount going directly to the widow by approximately $1,100,000.00. The benefit to the children by virtue of the disclaimer is claimed to be that the sum available for distribution to these grandchildren when their mother dies (which is estimated to be in approximately 43 years, (see § 8.01-419 of the Code of Virginia», will be $61,756,938.00 instead of $60,193,069.00. This benefit is contingent upon a number of assumptions, including, but not limited to, the children’s grandmother and mother (and possibly their father) not expending the money or otherwise disposing of the monies in a fashion not now contemplated.

Although the interest of the children in the inter vivos trust set up by their grandfather is only that of contingent remaindermen, it is nevertheless an expectancy now in existence which cannot be altered by the voluntary acts of others. It can be defeated only by their mother surviving her mother. If the mother of the three children predeceases her mother (“the widow”), the children will then have a vested right to the per stirpes distribution of one third of the trust corpus.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.