Richmond County Circuit Court July 9, 1997, Case No. ML-4225 (Earley v. Weis)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-07-1997
By Judge James B. Wilkinson
This cause of action stems from an automobile accident in which the plaintiff was injured. The parties are before toe court on toe defendant's motion in limine to exclude medical bills which were waived by toe Medical College of Virginia (MCV) and thereby prevent toe plaintiff ton claiming them as special damages at trial.
Urn plaintiff is insumí by Trigon Blue Cross/Bke Shield. His policy requires a pre-admission review, whereby the hospital must contact Trigon and receive approval before admitting him as a patient. MCV Med to follow this procedure, so Trigon retosed to cover the hospital bill of $13,106.87. MCV waived this bill completely.
Furthermore, a bill was submitted to Trigon for treatment rendered by MCV Associated Physicians in toe amount of $3,596.00. Upon review of the bill and comparison to a governmental study relating to toe cost of toe procedure performed, Trigon agreed to pay $1,858.50. MCV Associated Physicians waived toe outstanding $1,634.50.
The plaintiff seeks to include toe waived amounts, a total of $14,741.37, in his special damages. The defendant moved toe court to exclude these hills, which motion the court took tinder advisement.
*100
Issue
Whether toe plaintiff may claim bills which were waived by toe medical providers as special damages.
Discussion
An injured party may recover damages for which he has been compensated by way of an insurance policy he has maintained. This rule, known as toe collateral source rule, is long established in Virginia and serves to fully compensate a plaintiff for damages incurred by toe defendant's negligence, as well as insuring that a defendant is held accountable for all toe damage his wrong effects. See, Johnson v. Kellam, 162 Va. 757, 764, 175 S.E. 634 (1934); Schickling v. Aspinall, 235 Va. 472, 474-75, 369 S.E.2d 172 (1988).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit