Virginia Beach County Circuit Court September 17, 1997, Case No. (Law) CL96-2482 (Miller v. Russo)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-09-1997

By Judge Jerome B. Friedman

This automobile accident case was tried to a jury on July 16,1997. At trial, toe defendant admitted negligence, leaving only toe issue of damages for toe jury’s determination. Ibis action arises from a May 22, 1996, accident in which plaintiff claims to have injured his knees, wrists, and lower back. The plaintiff claimed $3,599.12 in medical bills and $3,514.00 in lost wages, for a total of $7,113.12 in special damages. The jury awarded toe plaintiff damages in toe amount of $2,942.16, which figure approximately equals toe amount of medical bills and lost wages claimed to have been incurred by plaintiff through May 31, 1996. The plaintiff has moved for a new trial or, in toe alternative, additusr, seeking the award of additional damages. The court took the plaintiffs motion under advisement, and both parties subsequently filed briefs. For toe reasons set forth below, this court denies plaintiffs motion tor a new trial or additar and confirms toe jury’s verdict

The court is guided by toe Supreme Court’s analysis in Bradner v. Mitchell, 234 Va. 483 (1987), of toe cases which address toe adequacy of jury verdicts. Where toe evidence of special damages is tmcontroveited and so complete that no rational fect-finder could disregard it, it must be considered as a fixed, constituent part of toe verdict Bradner at 487. On toe other hand, whore toe plaintiffs evidence of special damages is controverted, doubtful as to nature and extent or subject to substantial question whether attributable to toe defendant’s wrong or to some other cause, toen toe claimed special damages should not be considered & fixed part of toe verdict In such a case, a *356rational fact-finder might property find the plaintiff entitled to considerably less than the amount claimed as special damages. Bradner at 487-88.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.