Chesterfield County Circuit Court October 21, 1997, Case No. CH96-1626 (Williams v. Neff)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-10-1997

By Judge Herbert C. Gill, Jr.

The parties were before the Court by counsel on October 10, 1997, for a hearing on defendants’ motions for summary judgment The Court, having reviewed the memoranda of counsel, pertinent sections of the Virginia Code, and applicable case law, determines that the motions for summary judgment should be granted.

The Neffs’ motion for summary judgment relies on Virginia Code § 55-519 and toe doctrine of caveat emptor. In response, toe plaintiffs argue fraud on toe part of toe Neffs. Under Virginia law, three components must be alleged to plead fraud: (1) either a concealment of a material fact if there exists a duty to disclose or misrepresentation of a pre-existing material fact, (2) reliance on toé concealment or misrepresentation inducing toe plaintiff to act, and (3) injury to toe plaintiff resulting from such concealment or misrepresentation. Lloyd v. Smith, 150 Va. 132 (1928). Virginia Code § 55-519 allows toe owner of real properly to provide toe buyer with a disclaimer statement indicating that “toe owner makes no representations or warranties as to toe condition of tiie real property or any improvements thereon and that the purchaser will be receiving toe real property ’as-is,' that is, with all defects which may exist, if any, except as otherwise provided for in toe real estate contract” Va. Code § 55-519 (Michie 1950 as amended), hi the case at hand, toe Neffs provided such a disclaimer statement to toe plaintiffs, Mr. and Mrs. Williams, stating specifically that toe plaintiffs took toe property “as-is” with no representations *465or warranties. Thus, the Neffs had no duty to disclose any defects in the real property under the statute.

The Virginia Supreme Court continues to reaffirm that the doctrine of caveat emptor is applicable in the state of Virginia. See Boris v. Hill, 237 Va. 160 (1989), and Virginia Natural Gas Co. v. Hamilton, 249 Va. 449 (1995).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.