Newport News County Circuit Court November 14, 1997, Case No. (Law) 24676-VA (Carmichael v. Newport News School Board)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-11-1997

By Judge Verbena M. Askew

The defendant, Newport News School Board, filed a demurrer on August 13, 1997. A Memorandum in support of the demurrer was submitted to die court on September 17,1997. Plaintiff Carmichael filed a Motion to Overrule Demurrer on September 7,1997. A Memorandum in support of Plaintiffs motion was filed on October 1, 1997. A hearing on the above motions was held on October 3, 1997. For the reasons stated below, the Court overrules the defendant’s demurrer.

Background

On September 7, 1995, Jerica Carmichael, a student at Warwick Intermediate Kindergarten, was a passenger on a school bus that was traveling on Jefferson Avenue. She was injured when the bus collided with a building. Jerica and her mother (“the Carmichaels”) are suing the Newport News School Board for a total of $16,500.00.

There is a dispute among the parties as to whether the school board is subject to the doctrine of sovereign immunity in this case. The school board contends that the Carmichaels’ motion for judgment is insufficient to state a cause of action against it because the motion for judgment alleges *44simple negligence, not gross negligence. Therefore, the school board requests that its demurrer be sustained on those grounds.

Discussion

In the instant case, the issue before the Court is whether the Carmichaels have stated a cause of action against the school board upon which relief can be granted.

A. Demurrer Standard

A demurrer tests the legal sufficiency of a motion for judgment. Elliott v. Shore Stop, Inc., 238 Va. 237, 239, 384 S.E.2d 752 (1989). A trial court is therefore confined to the facts alleged when analyzing the pleading; no consideration can be given to additional facts that may be asserted on brief or during oral argument. Id. at 240. The demurrer admits the truth of all material facts that are properly pleaded. Id.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.