North Dakota Supreme Court November 6, 1997, Criminal 970054 (City of Fargo v. Sivertson)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-11-1997

combined-opinion

MARING, Justice.

[¶ 1] The City of Fargo appeals from an order suppressing evidence in this DUI prosecution against Stanley Sivertson, because the arresting officer violated Sivertson’s Fourth Amendment rights against unreasonable search and seizure. We hold the arresting officer’s approach of Sivertson’s parked vehicle did not constitute a Fourth Amendment stop, and we reverse the order suppressing evidence and remand.

[¶2] The relevant facts are undisputed. On September 18, 1996 Police Officer Grant Benjamin was dispatched to the scene of an accident at South University Drive in Fargo to conduct an A.L.E.R.T. screening. South University Drive is a two lane one-way southbound street. When Officer Benjamin arrived at the scene, the accident vehicle was in the right lane and behind it were two police vehicles. Sivertson’s vehicle was stopped in the right lane about 20 yards behind the other police vehicles. Benjamin stopped his vehicle in the right lane about “10 to 12 car lengths” behind the accident location, a sufficient distance to allow Sivert-son room to pull into the left lane and proceed past the accident scene.

[¶ 3] Officer Benjamin testified two other vehicles passed by the scene in the left lane, but, as he watched for 30 seconds to a minute, Sivertson’s vehicle did not move. Benjamin testified:

A. At this time I believe the individual was waiting to approach the traffic stop believing he may know he needed to stop. I activated the arrow stick which directs traffic to go around my vehicle and I got out and approached the vehicle.

⅜ * ⅜ * ⅝ ⅝

Q. What did you observe at that point?

A. One male individual sitting in the vehicle fixated forward.

Q. Did he ever turn towards you?

A. Once I had knocked on the window.

⅜ * * * *

Q. When he turned and looked, did you notice anything unusual about his reaction?

A. As I stated, when I knocked on the window he appeared startled.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.