Court of Appeals of Washington March 30, 1998, 39296-4-I (State v. Granacki)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-03-1998

Agid, J.

The State appeals the trial court’s dismissal of its case against David Granacki based on the conduct of one of the State’s witnesses, a police detective, who remained in the courtroom to assist the prosecutor. The State concedes that the witness’s conduct was improper but argues it was not so egregious that dismissal was warranted. We disagree and affirm the trial court’s dismissal of the underlying action.

FACTS

Granacki was charged with two counts of second degree robbery, one count of attempted second degree robbery, one

*600

count of third degree theft, and one count of fourth degree assault. When the case proceeded to trial in July 1996, the trial court granted an agreed motion to exclude witnesses but allowed the deputy prosecutor to choose one police officer to remain in the courtroom to assist at counsel table during trial. That officer was Detective Steven Kelly of the Kent Police Department. After the jury was impaneled on August 5, the State introduced Kelly to the jury as the “lead detective” in the case. Kelly was present when the court informed the jury that all parties had been instructed to have no contact with the jurors.

During a 15-minute recess on the second morning of trial, defense counsel left the courtroom, leaving his notebooks and legal pads at counsel table. The legal pads contained notes about communications between Granacki and his attorneys, trial strategy and tactics, and communications between his attorneys. When defense counsel returned to the courtroom just before the court reconvened, the court clerk told him she had observed Detective Kelly looking at the top page of a legal pad on defense counsel’s table when she returned to the courtroom a few minutes earlier. When defense counsel returned to the courtroom shortly before the end of lunch recess, Detective Kelly was engaged in “earnest” conversation with a sitting juror in the hall outside the courtroom within earshot of other jurors waiting for the door to be unlocked.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.