Alaska Supreme Court March 13, 1998, S-7257 (Gates v. City of Tenakee Springs)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-03-1998

PER CURIAM.

I.

INTRODUCTION

Joni Gates appeals the superior court’s order on remand denying her motion for relief from judgment. We affirm.

*1036

II.

FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS

This is the third time that this case has come before this court. The following facts are taken from

Gates v. City of Tenakee Springs,

Mem. Op. & J. No. 0744 (Alaska, October 26,1994)

(Gates

II):

In

Gates v. City of Tenakee Springs,

822 P.2d 455 (Alaska 1991), Gates claimed, inter alia, that the City of Tenakee Springs negligently removed a fence, resulting in damage to her property. The trial court granted summary judgment in favor of Tenakee Springs. One basis for the trial court’s decision was that Tenakee Springs had municipal immunity from Gates’ claims.

Id.

at 457. We held that Tenakee Springs’ decision to remove the fence was protected, but that the manner in which the fence was removed was not immune. Therefore, if negligent removal caused Gates’ damages, she should be compensated. The case was remanded to determine whether Gates’ alleged damages were the result of negligent removal of the fence.

Id.

at 459. Additionally, the trial court was to determine the extent of the damage caused by the method Tenakee Springs selected to remove the fence.

Id.

The trial on remand was rescheduled to take place in Juneau at 9:30 a.m. on October 30, 1992. Gates failed to appear. She did not contact the clerk of court’s office, the assigned judge’s chambers, the opposing party or its attorney. Tenakee Springs moved ex parte for and was granted entry of judgment by default under Alaska Civil Rule 55(c)(1).

On November 4, 1992, Gates moved to reschedule the trial. She claimed she was unable to attend the October 30 trial because of a medical emergency. Gates explained that she had an appointment in Juneau with Dr. Nell Wagoner on October 29, 1992, for a medical examination. She had scheduled the examination for the same week as the trial to save making an extra trip to Juneau. After examining Gates, Dr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.