Court of Appeals of Alaska March 27, 1998, A-6619 (Gilley v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-03-1998
MANNHEIMER, Judge.
In 1997, Herbert James Gilley, Jr., was convicted of felony driving while intoxicated, AS 28.35.030(a), (n). Gilley had two prior felony convictions, one from 1993 and the other from 1977. The question in this case is whether the superior court was obliged to treat Gilley as a third felony offender for purposes of presumptive sentencing, or whether (as Gilley contends) the superior court had the discretion to ignore the 1977 felony conviction and to treat Gilley as a second felony offender. Gilley contends that his sentence must be vacated because the superior court did not realize that it had the discretion to sentence him as a second felony offender. For the reasons explained here, we hold that the superior court was obliged to treat Gilley as a third felony offender, and we therefore affirm his sentence.
As this court recognized in
Juneby v. State,
641 P.2d 823, 831 n. 12 (Alaska App. 1982),
modified on other grounds,
665 P.2d 30 (Alaska App.1983), Gilley’s status as a second or third felony offender hinges on the relationship between, on the one hand, the definitions of “second felony offender” and “third felony offender” codified in AS 12.55.185 and, on the other, the provisions of AS 12.55.145(a) and (f) that explain what constitutes a “prior conviction” for presumptive sentencing purposes.
Under the presumptive sentencing laws, a defendant is considered a “second felony offender” if “the defendant previously has been convicted of a felony”. AS 12.55.185(12). A defendant is considered a “third felony offender” if “the defendant has been at least twice previously convicted of a felony”. AS 12.55.185(14). Gilley was convicted of third-degree assault in 1993, and he was convicted of assault with a dangerous weapon (under the former criminal code) in 1977. Because Gilley “has been ... twice previously convicted of a felony”, he would ordinarily be classified as a third felony offender.
AS 12.55.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit