Court of Appeals of South Carolina June 15, 1998, 2851 (Eldridge v. City of Greenwood)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-06-1998

CURETON, Judge:

This appeal concerns the property interests the Railroad

1

acquired in different segments of a rail corridor that ran through the middle of the town of Greenwood, S.C. The Railroad removed the tracks from this corridor in the 1980’s as part of a project to relocate the line to the outskirts of town.

We initially address subject matter jurisdiction and conclude this action is properly before us. The other issues on appeal challenge the trial court’s determination that the Railroad obtained only an easement in three segments of the rail corridor: (1) the property presumed granted to the Railroad under its charter, (2) the property obtained from the Partlow family in the 1850’s through condemnation proceedings, and (3) the property acquired by deed from the Jones family in 1849.

We agree the Railroad obtained only an easement in the properties acquired by deed and by the statutory presumption of grant provisions in the Railroad’s charter, but hold the Railroad had a fee simple interest in the property acquired by

*406

condemnation. We therefore affirm in part and reverse in part.

I. FACTS

After relocation of the tracks, the Railroad quitclaimed the appropriate portions of its interest in the rail corridor to the City and County of Greenwood. The City and County then transferred their interests to the South Carolina Highway Department.

2

The Respondents, who consist of two classes of plaintiffs,

3

claim title reverted to them upon the Railroad’s abandonment of the rail corridor. This court reviewed the summary judgment stage of this litigation in

Eldridge v. City of Greenwood,

300 S.C. 369, 388 S.E.2d 247 (Ct.App.1989)

(Eldridge I),

and we refer the reader to that decision for a thorough discussion of the facts.

II. SUBJECT MATTER JURISDICTION

Initially, we are faced with the question of subject-matter jurisdiction, which was not raised at the summary judgment stage reviewed in

Eldridge I.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.