Court of Appeals of Georgia June 3, 1998, A98A0521 (Lloyd v. Kramer)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-06-1998

Judge Harold R. Banke.

Ann Lloyd sued her podiatrist, Jerald N. Kramer and his professional corporation, Dr. Jerald N. Kramer, R C., for medical malpractice, fraud, battery, breach of fiduciary duty, punitive damages, and

*373

costs. Enumerating two errors, Lloyd contests the partial summary judgment awarded to Kramer on all her claims except for malpractice.

The underlying case arose after Kramer operated on Lloyd’s right foot. Lloyd asserted that Kramer subjected her to inappropriate and unnecessary surgery during which he fused the joints of three toes and inserted pins in them and also performed a metatarsal osteotomy to shorten her second toe. Lloyd alleged that in obtaining her consent to medical treatment, Kramer fraudulently, knowingly, and deliberately made material misrepresentations both as to the nature of her medical condition and as to the need for surgery to correct it.

In moving for partial summary judgment, Kramer attacked one of the requisite elements of a fraud claim, claiming that Lloyd failed to show that he made a false representation to her with the intent to deceive. In granting partial summary judgment, the trial court found that Lloyd failed to offer evidence to show that Kramer knew that the procedures were unnecessary or that Kramer made fraudulent misrepresentations to her. The court decided that the written consent to medical treatment form foreclosed the battery claim. The court held that because Lloyd’s claim for breach of fiduciary duty was based on fraud and battery, it necessarily failed. Lloyd appeals this judgment.

Held:

1. Lloyd contends that the trial court erred in granting partial summary judgment. She claims that the . record is replete with evidence from which fraud can reasonably be inferred.

Since fraud is inherently subtle, slight circumstances of fraud may be sufficient to establish a proper case.

McNeil v. Cowart,

186 Ga. App. 411, 412 (1) (367 SE2d 291) (1988). OCGA § 23-2-57.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.