Utah Supreme Court December 29, 1998, 950256 (Brinton v. IHC Hospitals, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-12-1998
STEWART, Justice:
Plaintiff James A. Brinton appeals the district court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of defendant IHC Hospitals, Inc. (“IHC”). Dr. Brinton was a staff member at two IHC hospitals in Utah County for several years. IHC imposed multiple practice restrictions on him and then revoked his hospital privileges. Dr. Brinton then filed suit against IHC in district court.
In the district court, Dr. Brinton asserted nine causes of action, accompanied by demands for compensatory and punitive damages.
1
He also asserted three claims for injunctive or declaratory relief, demanding reinstatement. The trial court decided that each of his claims was ultimately grounded in the assertion that IHC had violated the contractual bylaws governing Dr. Brinton’s staff privileges. On cross-motions for summary judgment, the district court ruled in IHC’s favor. The court held that Dr. Brinton had waived most of his assertions of contractual violations of the bylaws, and for those claims not waived, that IHC had substantially complied with its bylaws. The district court ruled that none of Dr. Brinton’s claims for relief could stand without a showing of substantial violation of the bylaws and dismissed his claims. We affirm.
I. BACKGROUND
Dr. Brinton worked at both Utah Valley Regional Medical Center and Orem Valley Hospital (collectively “the Hospital”). IHC operates both facilities under a unified administrative structure. As a condition to obtaining staff privileges, Dr. Brinton agreed to be bound by Hospital Bylaws (the “Bylaws”). The Bylaws incorporated another document known as the Fair Hearing Plan (“FHP”), which dictates specific procedures for conducting peer review of physicians on staff at the Hospital.
The Hospital’s administration is divided into nineteen staff departments. Dr. Brinton belonged to the obstetrics and gynecology (“OB-GYN”) department.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit