Court of Appeals of North Carolina April 7, 1998, COA97-879 (State Auto Insurance Companies v. McClamroch)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-04-1998
EAGLES, Judge.
We first consider whether the trial court erred in granting summary judgment because plaintiff is not the correct party plaintiff. Defendants argue that “State Auto Insurance Companies” is not the proper plaintiff because the insurance policy being reviewed was issued by “State Automobile Mutual Insurance Company,” a separate legal entity. Accordingly, defendants argue that plaintiff has not carried its burden of proving that it had standing to sue.
Plaintiff first contends that defendants failed to raise this matter in the trial court and cannot raise it for the first time on appeal. Plaintiff additionally states that the “policy was issued by State Automobile Mutual Insurance Company, which makes up one part of the ‘State Auto Insurance Companies’ umbrella.” Plaintiff argues that the fact that it is proceeding under the name of its umbrella organization is irrelevant to the substantive issues in this case.
We hold that State Auto Insurance Companies had standing to sue. State Automobile Mutual Insurance Company is not a separate legal entity from State Auto Insurance Companies, it is a corporate division of State Auto Insurance Companies. The policy issued to the McClamrochs has a “State Auto Insurance Companies” logo on it, indicating State Automobile Mutual Insurance Company’s affiliation with State Auto Insurance Companies. Accordingly, it was proper for
*217
plaintiff to proceed under the name of its umbrella organization. The assignment of error is overruled.
We next consider whether the trial court erred in refusing to transfer venue to Guilford County because Forsyth County has no connection to the case. Defendants argue that this case is the factual twin of
USAA v. Simpson,
COA 96-636 (unpublished opinion, June 3, 1996),
petition for disc, review pending.
The Simpsons are defendants in the
Kaplan
case. USAA, the Simpsons’ insurer, retained a lawyer to defend the Simpsons under a reservation of rights.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit