Court of Appeals of Georgia January 8, 1998, A97A1991 (Marshall v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-01-1998

Judge Harold R. Banke.

Fred James Marshall was convicted of burglary. He enumerates two errors on appeal.

This case arose after Marshall cut the screen and entered a window into the home the two elderly female victims shared. The victims, sisters, awoke to discover that two pocketbooks containing approximately $60 were missing. The responding officer searched the area surrounding the house and found the purses in a nearby dumpster. Inside one, he found a rubber glove which the victims denied was theirs.

Three months later, the victims were burglarized a second time and raped. Marshall was arrested but not charged in the crimes. He

*117

then became a suspect in the initial burglary, at which point the authorities sent the rubber glove to the crime lab, three months after the crime at issue here. Latent prints from all five fingers on Marshall’s right hand were found on the glove.

Held,'.

1. Marshall’s rights to confrontation and a thorough and sifting cross-examination were not abridged by constraints placed on his inquiry into the delay in sending the glove to the crime lab. After Marshall moved in limine to exclude any reference to the rape, the State agreed to avoid that topic. In conjunction with argument on that motion, however, the State asked that Marshall refrain from raising the issue of law enforcement’s failure to have the glove tested immediately after the first burglary. Over Marshall’s protest that he should be permitted to explore what he characterized as “sloppy police work,” the trial court held that if Marshall broached the issue, the State could explain the delay with testimony that Marshall did not become a suspect until the rape and second burglary.

“The object of all legal investigation is the discovery of truth.” OCGA § 24-1-2. Marshall in effect sought to mislead the jury by discrediting law enforcement for its investigatory delay, while preventing the State from offering an explanation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.