Court of Appeals of Georgia September 21, 1998, A98A1272 (Horton v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-09-1998
Beasley, Judge.
Convicted and sentenced on three counts of armed robbery (OCGA § 16-8-41) and one count of theft by taking (OCGA § 16-8-2), Vershorn Horton enumerates three errors: (i) the court found he did not establish a prima facie case of race discrimination in the State’s exercise of its peremptory jury challenges; (ii) the court improperly intimated he was guilty when it informed the jury that a co-indictee had pled guilty and had been sentenced; and (iii) he was denied effective assistance by counsel’s failing to move for a mistrial when the court spoke of the co-indictee’s guilty plea.
1. Horton is of a minority race, and the jury venire of thirty-four persons included six members of that race, two of whom were stricken by the State in exercising six peremptory strikes. Horton struck another, and the remaining three members of his race served on the twelve-person jury.
*479
After jury selection, Horton objected under
Batson v.
Kentucky
1
and asked the court to require the State to identify the reasons for striking the two. The court found he had not established a prima facie case of purposeful race discrimination and denied the request.
A
Batson
challenge is not only to protect a defendant’s right to a trial by his peers. Since
Strauder v. West
Virginia,
2
the United States Supreme Court has “recognized that by denying a person participation in jury service on account of his race, the State unconstitutionally discriminate^] against the excluded juror. [Cits.]”
3
Moreover, “[t]he harm from discriminatory jury selection extends beyond that inflicted on the defendant and the excluded juror to touch the entire community. Selection procedures that purposefully exclude black persons from juries undermine public confidence in the fairness of our system of justice. [Cits.]”
4
Thus there are three values to be served by assuring race-neutral jury selection.
5
Consequently, racially-motivated exclusion of members of the majority race is also prohibited.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit