Court of Appeals of Washington November 30, 1998, 40849-6-I (Christenson v. McDuffy)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-11-1998
Becker, J.
A statute permits an owner of real property to obtain summary relief from a frivolous lien through a show cause hearing. Appellant Laura Christenson had already sold her property when she attempted to use the frivolous lien statute to contest a lien previously placed against the property. Because she was no longer the owner, Christenson lacked standing to proceed under the frivolous lien statute. We affirm the order dismissing her lawsuit.
*179
Laura Christenson retained R.L. McDuffy to assist her in preparing a short plat application to subdivide her property-in Marysville. McDuffy sent Christenson a bill when he completed the documents for that work. Christenson recorded the documents, but did not pay McDuffy. McDuffy then filed a lien against Christenson’s property in the amount of $2,400.
On March 3, 1997, the day McDuffy filed the lien, Christenson was in the final stages of selling her property. The next day, March 4, she entered into a “Special Indemnity Agreement” with a title company. The agreement provided that the title company would hold $3,600 of the proceeds from the sale of the property until McDu’ffy’s lien was resolved. The agreement had the effect of clearing title to the property. Christenson completed the sale of the property on that day.
On March 7, Christenson filed an application in superior court for an order directing McDuffy to show cause why his lien should not be quashed as frivolous. She asked that title to the property be quieted to Christenson and her successors, and requested attorney fees. In her application, Christenson alleged that McDuffy filed his lien “to extort sums in excess of the amounts agreed by delaying the closing of my sale of the subject property.”
After a hearing, the trial court found that Christenson had no standing to proceed with her claim because she was no longer an owner of the real property subject to McDuffy’s lien at the time she commenced her action.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit