Texas Court of Appeals, 10th District (Waco) February 18, 1998, 10-97-036-CR (Bumguardner v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-02-1998

OPINION

DAVIS, Chief Justice.

A jury convicted Michael Lee Bumguard-ner of the offense of murder and assessed punishment at twenty three years’ confinement.

See

Tex. Pen.Code Ann. § 19.02 (Vernon 1994).

In his first point of error, Bumguardner alleges that the evidence is factually insufficient to establish beyond a reasonable doubt that he did not shoot the victim in self-defense. The second point of error asserts that the court erred in submitting a jury instruction which limited his right of self-defense. Point of error three alleges that the jury determined his sentence by lot. The fourth point of error asserts that the evidence is factually sufficient to prove that he acted in the heat of sudden passion.

*173

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

Bumguardner shot James “Scooter” Hinton on September 29, 1995 at approximately 11:30 PM in the parking lot of the Continental Cowboy. Testimony revealed that Hinton had been seeing Bumguardner’s wife, Sheila. Earlier in the day, Bumguardner and his friend, James Morgan, saw Sheila, Hinton, “Ty” Summey, and Steven Harper entering a convenience store in McGregor. Morgan pulled his truck into the parking lot, and Bumguardner went into the store to talk to Sheila. Bumguardner and Sheila went outside the store to talk while the three men remained in the store.

After arguing with Sheila, Bumguardner got into Morgan’s truck, and they started to leave when Hinton and Summey walked outside the store. Bumguardner got out of the truck, and the men began cursing at each other. Hinton removed his cowboy hat and untucked his shirt as if getting ready for a fight. The store clerk came out and separated the men, and Bumguardner left.

That evening, Bumguardner went to the Continental Cowboy looking for Sheila. Not finding her, he walked toward his truck in the parking lot as Sheila, Hinton, Summey, and Harper were exiting their vehicle. The men began arguing and cursing. Bumguard-ner pulled out a gun and waved it in the air.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.