Supreme Court of Vermont September 10, 1998, 97-314 (In Re Professional Nurses Service, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-09-1998

Professional Nurses Service, Inc. (PNS) appeals from a decision of the Commissioner of the Department of Banking, Insurance, Securities and Health Care Administration, •which denied PNS’s application for a certificate of need (CON) to offer a full range of nurse-aide and other therapeutic services. The CON is necessary for PNS to seek certification as a Medicare home health agency. PNS claims that the Commissioner erred by (1) failing to make findings of fact on whether a new home health agency is needed as a result of changes in the health care market, (2) concluding that PNS’s proposal for a new home health agency is not consistent with the health resource management plan as required by 18 VS.A. § 9437(5), (3) failing to comply with the timetable of the health resource management plan, and (4) failing to assert jurisdiction over other non-Medicare certified home health providers. We affirm.

The Vermont Legislature has provided that “[n]o new institutional health service shall be offered or developed within this state by any person, without a determination of need and issuance of a certificate of need by the commissioner . . .’ .” 18 VS.A. § 9434(a). Among the purposes of the CON program are: to avoid unnecessary duplication of services, to contain the cost of services, and to promote a rational allocation of health care resources.

Id.

§ 9431. In determining whether to grant a CON, the Commissioner must consider the general criteria set forth in 18 VS.A. § 9436(a), and to grant a CON, the Commissioner must make the five findings required by 18 VS.A. § 9437, sometimes called the mandatory criteria. The fifth of the mandatory criteria is the criterion relevant to this case. It provides that the proposed new service must be consistent with the health resource management plan. See 18 VS.A. § 9437(5).

The health resource management plan

is a plan for distribution of health services in Vermont. See 1991, No. 160 (Adj. Sess.), § 1, superseded by 1995, No. 180 (Adj. Sess.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.