Court of Appeals of Kentucky November 25, 1998, 1997-CA-000845-MR (Matthews v. G & B TRUCKING, INC.)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-11-1998

*329

OPINION

KNOPF, Judge:

This is an appeal from a summary judgment dismissing an action against an employer as barred by the exclusive liability provision of the Workers’ Compensation Act. This Court finds that an employer who fails to secure payment of workers’ compensation benefits is not entitled to benefit from the exclusive liability provision, even if an “up-the-ladder” contractor is liable for payment of benefits. Therefore, the trial court’s dismissal of the claim is vacated, and the action is remanded for further proceedings on the merits.

The appellant, Michael Matthews, was employed by the appellee, G & B Trucking, Inc., as a coal truck driver. G & B Trucking contracted with Pyramid Mining, Inc. to haul coal from Goshen Mines to Pyramid Mines. On June 13, 1994, Matthews was injured while hauling coal for G & B Trucking. At the time of the injury, G & B Trucking did not have workers’ compensation coverage for its employees.

Subsequently, Matthews brought a civil action against G & B Trucking, and its owner, Grover F. Baker. Matthews also asserted claims against Northland Insurance Company, the vehicle’s insurer, and Graward General, his own motor vehicle insurance carrier. G & B Trucking filed a third-party complaint against Northland, Wausau Insurance Company, and the Raymond H. Nelson Insurance Agency, seeking a declaration of rights that G & B Trucking had workers’ compensation coverage, or in the alternative that the agency was negligent for failing to secure the insurance.

Matthews also filed a workers’ compensation claim against Pyramid Mining, which was ultimately settled. While the workers’ compensation claim was pending, the trial court held the tort action in abeyance. After the trial court removed the case from abeyance, Baker and G & B Trucking filed a motion for summary judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.