Missouri Court of Appeals December 14, 1998, 22402 (Branson West, Inc. v. City of Branson)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-12-1998
CROW, Judge.
Plaintiff, Branson West, Inc., a Missouri corporation, sued the City of Branson (“City”) and Beemer Construction Company, Inc. (“Beemer”). This opinion henceforth refers to City and Beemer collectively as “Defendants.”
Plaintiffs petition pled,
inter alia)
that Plaintiff granted City a “sanitary sewer easement” across land owned by Plaintiff, that City employed Beemer “as contractor on the sewer project,” that Defendants exceeded the scope of the easement in that Beemer “clear cut” the entire width and length of the easement and “bulldozefd] said strip and did remove every single tree therefrom, without any attempt whatsoever to preserve such trees as it was not necessary to remove,” and that such activity “greatly devalued not only the property over which [Defendants] have an easement, but the adjoining property as well, to Plaintiffs damage in the amount of four million dollars.”
Beemer filed a motion for summary judgment. So did City. The trial court granted the motions and entered judgment in favor of Defendants.
Plaintiff appeals, maintaining there is an unresolved issue of material fact, i.e., whether Defendants exceeded their rights under the easement by cutting more trees than were “reasonably necessary to construct the sewer line.”
Plaintiff granted the easement to City in a document denominated “Grant of Utility
*605
Easement.” This opinion henceforth refers to that document as “the Grant.”
The Grant provides,
inter alia:
“Branson West Inc., hereby grants to the City of Branson ... a right of way and easement to build, construct reconstruct, and operate and maintain utility lines together with any and all appurtenances thereto; said utility lines and appurtenances to be of such size and character as grantee may determine, on over, across, and under all that certain real property situated in the City of Branson ... particularly described as follows[.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit