Supreme Court of Rhode Island May 29, 1998, 96-371-Appeal (Day v. Caslowitz)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-05-1998

OPINION

FLANDERS, Justice.

This appeal requires us to determine the scope of the public-safety officer's rule (the rule).

1

In this case the plaintiff police officer slipped, fell, and injured himself upon the defendant homeowner’s snow- and ice-covered walkway while he was investigating an activated home-security alarm on the premises. In these circumstances does the rule bar the injured police officer’s negligence claim against the homeowner? Yes, we conclude, for the reasons discussed below.

The plaintiff police officer, Timothy Day, appeals from a Superior Court order granting summary judgment for defendant property owner, Monroe L. Caslowitz. The hearing justice’s ruling in favor of defendant was based upon the applicability of the rule to the factual situation described in plaintiffs complaint. On appeal plaintiff argues that the rule was misapplied in this case. He claims that the rule only bars suits by public-safety officers against property owners for their alleged acts of ordinary negligence that both create an emergency situation requiring the officer’s presence at the place of injury and cause the officer’s injury. Because the reason for the officer’s coming to the scene in this case (the triggering of a home-security alarm) was different from the alleged cause of the officer’s injury (the property owner’s putative negligence in failing to clear the walkway of snow and ice), plaintiff claims that the rule should not bar his action.

The defendant, on the other hand, contends that the rule precludes suits against property owners and occupiers for their alleged acts of ordinary negligence that cause injury to public-safety officers while they are responding to work-related emergency situations. Even though defendant’s alleged negligence in failing to clear the walkway of snow and ice was not the cause of the officer’s presence at the scene, the rule, defendant claims, is still applicable in this situation to bar plaintiffs suit.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.