District Court, S.D. New York September 29, 1998, 97 CIV. 7572 MGC, 97 CIV. 7574 MGC (Nisselson v. DeWitt Stern Group, Inc. (In Re UFG International, Inc.))

Also known as

United States · · · 29-09-1998

OPINION

CEDARBAUM, District Judge.

Alan Nisselson, Chapter 11 Trustee of debtor UFG International, Inc. (“UFG”), brought this adversary proceeding against

*53

DeWitt Stern Group, Ine. (“DSG”), DeWitt Stern Imperatore, Ltd. (“DSI”), Paul Olshen and Roger Kluge. The complaint seeks damages and other relief for breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty, conversion and misappropriation by Olshen and Kluge, unfair competition on the part of all defendants, and unjust enrichment on the part of DSG and DSI. The complaint also seeks turnover and an accounting with respect to DSG and DSI. Defendants moved to withdraw the reference to the bankruptcy court, and for summary judgment on all claims on the grounds that (1) the covenants not to compete entered into by Olshen and Kluge are not enforceable; and (2) the information allegedly misappropriated by Olshen and Kluge was not confidential. At oral argument, I granted defendants’ motion to withdraw the reference. For the reasons that follow, defendants’ motion for summary judgment also is granted.

UNDISPUTED FACTS

Prior to filing for bankruptcy on August 22, 1995, UFG was an insurance brokerage firm that placed casualty and property insurance for commercial customers as well as other lines of insurance. From about 1962 to June 23,1995, Olshen was employed by UFG and its predecessors in generating and writing business for UFG’s commercial lines department. From about April 1964 to June 23, 1995, Kluge was employed by UFG and its predecessors as manager of the commercial lines department. In affidavits submitted by Olshen and Kluge, defendants assert that the commercial customers of UFG were readily ascertainable without access to the business files because the customers were engaged in business at advertised locations. Plaintiff has not presented evidence contradicting these sworn statements.

On about October 26,1987, Olshen entered into a written agreement with BRI Holding Corp.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.