Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania January 26, 1998, 2087 and 2166 C.D. 1996 (Pinnacle Health Hospitals v. Dauphin County Board of Assessment Appeals)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-01-1998
DOYLE, Judge.
Before this Court are the consolidated cross-appeals of the Pinnacle Health Hospitals, successor by merger to Harrisburg Hospital (Hospital),
1
and the County of Dauphin, School District of Harrisburg, and the City of Harrisburg (collectively, the County) from two orders of the Court of Common Pleas of Dauphin County. The first order, issued on March 23, 1995, granted the Hospital’s petition to remove its properties from the tax assessment rolls for calendar year 1993 and fiscal year 1993-1994, but denied the Hospital’s request for further reinstatement of its tax exemption for 1994 and subsequent years. The second order, entered on June 24, 1996, likewise denied the Hospital’s petition to have its tax-exempt status restored. The Hospital appeals from both the March 23, 1995 order and the June 24, 1996 order. The County appeals from the March 23,1995 order only.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
The Common Pleas Court made extensive findings of fact in its decision in
Harrisburg Hospital v. Dauphin County Board of Assessment Appeal,
116 Dauph. 193 (C.P.Pa.1996), which may be generally summarized as follows.
Histoiy and Community Services
The Hospital is a Pennsylvania non-profit corporation and is a tax exempt charity for federal tax purposes.
2
It was founded in 1873 through a combination of public contributions and private charity, and has evolved from a single building and medical treatment center into a multi-structure acute-care teaching hospital with more than 471 beds. Historically, the Hospital has always enjoyed a charitable exemption from local real estate taxes.
The evolution of the Hospital into a modem medical facility was financed largely through public and private contributions. In recent years, the Hospital has received substantial donations from the community in the form of contributions, gifts, grants and volun
*1287
teer services in the following amounts: $1,744,076 in 1992; $1,659,850 in 1993; and $2,224,887 in 1994.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit