Court of Appeals of Wisconsin May 12, 1998, 96-2324 (Conroy v. Marquette University)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-05-1998

CURLEY, J.

Marquette University and its insurer, St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Company,

*83

appeal from the judgment entered against them following a jury verdict in favor of Shauna Conroy. The jury found Marquette negligent for allowing Conroy, a student employee, to conduct the dormitory room checkout of a recently expelled student who later attacked Conroy off campus, causing serious injuries. The jury awarded Conroy $125,000 in damages. Marquette argues that the trial court erred by: (1) denying Marquette's motion for dismissal based on public policy considerations; (2) changing the verdict question and reinstructing the jury after the jury had begun their deliberations; (3) submitting a verdict question concerning contributory negligence; (4) directing a verdict on the question of whether the worker's compensation law was the sole remedy available to the plaintiff; and (5) finding that there was sufficient evidence to sustain a finding of causation. Because we conclude that, under these unique facts, public policy considerations prevent Conroy from recovering from Marquette, we reverse with instructions that this matter be dismissed with prejudice. Due to our ruling, it is unnecessary to address any other issues raised in this appeal.

I. Background.

In the summer of 1991, Conroy was both a student and an employee of Marquette University. While a student living in a dormitory, she was hired by the university as a Resident Assistant, and one of her tasks was to supervise the dormitory room check-out procedure whenever a student left the dormitory.

On July 16,1991, Alicia McDonald, a summer participant in a nationwide program for pre-college disadvantaged students, was expelled from Marquette for inappropriate behavior. The incidents which led to her dismissal consisted of McDonald insulting her

*84

English professor, arguing with fellow students in a classroom, and talking and acting inappropriately and bizarrely in a study hall.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.