Supreme Court of Iowa February 18, 1998, 97-816 (Sulma v. Iowa District Court for Washington County)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-02-1998
NEUMAN, Justice.
The district court found Andrew Sulma in contempt for refusing his former wife visitation with their two minor children. Sulma claims, by way of petition for certiorari, that the court’s order was not supported by substantial evidence. He also contests, on due process grounds, the conditions imposed for purging his contempt. We annul the writ.
I. Background. The marriage of Andrew and Tammy Sulma was dissolved in 1994. The court awarded them joint legal custody of their two children, Kathryn (bom in 1986) and Kenneth (born in 1988). The children were placed in Andrew’s primary care, subject to liberal visitation by Tammy. The court’s decree made plain that the decision was not based on any superior parenting skills held by Andrew, but on his “stability.” Tammy suffered from — and continues to battle — a variety of mental problems that prevent her from assuming the day-to-day care of the children. She was nevertheless viewed by the court as the more emotionally nurturing parent. Andrew, to his credit,
*321
could be counted on to provide the material necessities of life.
The controversy here concerns Andrew’s repeated resistance to Tammy’s visitation during the month of March 1997. The conflict had its origins in an incident occurring September 16, 1996, when Tammy arrived to pick up the children and, in Andrew’s words, “was intoxicated or having some difficulty because of slurred speech and irrational behavior.” Andrew confronted Tammy and stopped the children from getting into her car. Tammy reacted physically. She was ultimately arrested and, after pleading guilty to assault, was placed on probation. A no-contact order issued.
For several months after this incident the visitation went smoothly because Andrew’s sister, Marsha, facilitated the exchange of children from one parent to the other. Tammy remained in her car and Andrew stayed in his house.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit