Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania August 31, 1998 (Tricker v. Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-08-1998
*1080
PELLEGRINI, Judge.
The Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission (Turnpike Commission) appeals from the September 5, 1997 order of the Court of Common Pleas of Lawrence County (trial court) overruling its preliminary objections and convening a Board of Viewers to determine the damages owed to Dean G. Trieker (Property Owner) as a result of the Turnpike Commission’s
de facto
taking of his right-of-way.
Property Owner owns a parcel (Property) of woodlands in New Beaver Borough, Lawrence County, which he purchased by deed from Arnold D. Stambaugh and Sara V. Stambaugh, his wife (the Stambaughs), who had previously purchased it from Norman F. Voorhees (Voorhees). Voorhees also owned an adjoining parcel to the north of the Property.
1
Voorhees acquired ownership of the northern parcel from C.W. Knox (Knox), but Knox never owned the southern parcel, the Property now owned by Property Owner.
In 1942, before the Court of Quarter Sessions of Lawrence County, Knox acquired an easement from Edward and Florence Noggle (Noggle) across the Noggle’s property as a right-of-way.
2
Ownership of the Noggle property and its private right-of-way was subsequently transferred to Sara B. McCready (McCready). The following is a plot-plan of the various properties and the right-of-way:
[[Image here]]
Even though Property Owner had no express grant to use the right-of-way from the time he acquired his Property in 1962, he accessed it by way of the McCready right-of-way. Either Property Owner or his son used the McCready right-of-way at least one or two times per year from 1962 through 1988 and sometimes more often, to collect firewood and clear excess vegetation from the Property. Also between 1962 and 1988, Property Owner removed lumber for commercial use two or three times. Other than the right-of-way across the McCready property, Property Owner had no access to his Property from any public road.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit