Court of Appeals of Maryland May 20, 1998, 45 Sept. Term, 1997 (Dorsey v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-05-1998
BELL, Chief Judge.
This case presents the issue of the propriety of a circuit court’s dismissal of criminal charges against a defendant for failure of the State to bring the defendant to trial within 180 days, as required by Maryland Code (1971, Repl.Vol.1996), Article 27, § 591
1
and Maryland Rule 4-271
2
, notwithstanding that it was the defendant’s failure to appear on the scheduled trial date that resulted in the postponement of the case beyond the prescribed 180-day period. Stated differently, we must determine whether § 591 and Rule 4-271 impose a duty on the State to seek a postponement of trial beyond the 180-day limit and obtain a finding of good cause from the county administrative judge or that judge’s designee, when a petitioner, either voluntarily or involuntarily, absents him or herself from trial. We shall hold that, where a criminal defendant
*693
fails to appear at trial, that defendant bears the burden of going forward with evidence demonstrating that his or her failure to appear was not voluntary, but that the ultimate burden proof on the issue rests on the State; the State has the ultimate responsibility to prove that the defendant’s absence was a voluntary action and, thus, tantamount to seeking and consenting to a trial date in violation of § 591 and Rule 4-271.
I.
On October 2, 1995, the petitioner, Larry Emmanuel Dorsey, was indicted by a grand jury in the Circuit Court for Prince George’s County on charges of child abuse and battery. On October 20, 1995, he was arraigned. Defense counsel entered her appearance on the petitioner’s behalf on November 2, 1995. Section 591 and Rule 4-271, commonly referred to as the
Hicks
Rule, an eponym of the seminal case,
State v. Hicks,
285 Md. 310, 403 A.2d 356,
on motion for reconsiderar tion,
285 Md. 334, 403 A.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit