District of Columbia Court of Appeals May 14, 1998, 96-CV-549 (Wagshal v. Rigler)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-05-1998
STEADMAN, Associate Judge:
Unlike its federal counterpart, Superior Court Civil Rule 4(m) requires that both service of process and the filing of proof of such service be accomplished within sixty days of the filing of every civil complaint. On April 28, 1995, appellant Jerome S. Wag-shal, a retired attorney appearing
pro se,
filed suit against appellees Douglas V. Rigler and Julius Kaplan, also
pro se
attorneys.
1
Wagshal served process on Kaplan and Ri-gler on June 15 and June 22, 1995, respectively, within sixty days after the filing of the complaint. However, he did not file proof of service until July 5, 1995, eight days beyond the sixty-day period of Rule 4(m).
2
As a consequence of the failure to timely file proof of service, the Clerk of the Superi- or Court, pursuant to Rule 4(m), entered a dismissal of the complaint without prejudice on July 5, 1995. In fact, however, because the statute of limitations had run, this would in effect be a dismissal with prejudice assuming that Rigler and Kaplan raised that defense in a new action. Learning of the dismissal, Wagshal, two days later, filed a motion to vacate the dismissal under Rule 41(b), which provides in pertinent part:
Any order of dismissal entered sua sponte, including a dismissal for failure to effect service within the time prescribed in Rule 4(m), shall not take effect until fourteen (14) days after the date on which it is docketed and shall be vacated upon the granting of a motion filed by plaintiff within such 14 day period showing good cause why the case should not be dismissed.
3
The trial court “reluctantly” denied Wag-shal’s motion, ruling that his proffered explanations for failing to file timely proof of service did not demonstrate good cause.
4
*114
The decision whether to vacate a dismissal under Rule 41(b) is clearly a matter of trial court discretion.
Cameron v. Washington Metro. Area Transit Auth.,
649 A.2d 291, 294 (D.C.1994).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit